Conservative Commentator Allie Beth Stuckey Unleashes Scathing Rebuke of Candace Owens Over 'Heinous' Conspiracy Claims Involving Charlie Kirk's Widow

Washington, D.C. – November 13, 2025  In a blistering public takedown that has sent shockwaves through the fractured ranks of the American right, conservative podcaster Allie Beth Stuckey has accused fellow commentator Candace Owens of peddling "heinous" and baseless insinuations about Erika Kirk, the widow of slain Turning Point USA (TPUSA) founder Charlie Kirk. Stuckey's ferocious broadside, delivered on her popular podcast Relatable, arrives amid escalating tensions over Owens' relentless promotion of conspiracy theories surrounding Kirk's assassination two months ago—an eruption that threatens to deepen an already widening chasm within the conservative movement.

Stuckey, a longtime ally of TPUSA and a vocal defender of its mission to mobilize young conservatives, did not mince words in her episode released Wednesday, labeling Owens' rhetoric as not just "unbiblical" but a dangerous betrayal of the very values the late Kirk championed. "I'm not saying Candace said 'Erika did it'—but when you say 'everyone around Charlie betrayed him' and 'Turning Point is covering it up,' what do you think people are going to conclude?" Stuckey fumed, her voice dripping with exasperation. "Erika is the CEO. She's the widow. She's the one holding this organization together while raising their children and honoring his legacy. This isn't truth-seeking; it's character assassination wrapped in a podcast bow."

The feud traces its roots to September 10, when Kirk, the 32-year-old firebrand behind TPUSA's rapid rise as a powerhouse in youth conservatism, was gunned down onstage during a speech at Utah Valley University. Authorities swiftly arrested 22-year-old Tyler Robinson, a self-avowed leftist and college dropout, charging him with first-degree murder in what the FBI has described as a politically motivated lone-wolf attack. An autopsy revealed a single bullet lodged in Kirk's neck—a detail Owens has repeatedly branded "ridiculous" and suspicious, fueling her narrative of a broader cover-up.

Erika Kirk, who stepped into the CEO role at TPUSA following her husband's death, has largely remained above the fray, focusing instead on perpetuating his vision. Last month, she joined President Donald Trump at the White House to accept the Presidential Medal of Freedom on Kirk's behalf, a poignant moment captured in images showing her embracing Vice President JD Vance at a memorial event in Mississippi. Yet Owens, a former TPUSA affiliate whose relationship with the organization soured years ago, has seized on the tragedy to amplify wild allegations—from leaked text messages purportedly showing Kirk's frustrations with pro-Israel donors to eerie "prophecies" of his own demise.

In recent episodes of her self-titled show, Owens has stopped just short of direct accusations but has repeatedly invoked phrases like "an inside job" and "betrayal by everyone close to him," often juxtaposed with clips of Erika Kirk speaking publicly. "It will be much easier to control the spirit of Charlie Kirk than the actual living, breathing Charlie Kirk," Owens quipped in one segment, implying a shadowy succession plot at TPUSA. She has also questioned why Erika hasn't "demanded answers" from authorities and suggested the widow might be under the thumb of influential donors—claims that have ignited a firestorm online, with Owens' fans flooding social media with speculation that Erika herself was complicit.

The backlash has been swift and severe. Ben Shapiro, Owens' former Daily Wire colleague and a staunch Kirk supporter, accused her on The Megyn Kelly Show last week of effectively implicating Erika in the murder, calling her actions "evil." Owens fired back, branding Shapiro a "pathological liar" and claiming he fabricated the charge to silence her. Megyn Kelly, in a dramatic pivot during a subsequent live event, sided with Owens, announcing that Shapiro's assertion was unfounded based on her review of the clips. "Ben lied to my face," Kelly declared, drawing cheers from Owens' supporters but ire from conservatives who argue the podcaster's innuendos speak louder than her denials.

Enter Stuckey, the 36-year-old host of Relatable and a Blazetv contributor, who has positioned herself as the moral arbiter in this intra-right bloodletting. A mother of four and devout Christian, Stuckey—once a guest on Owens' old Daily Wire program—framed her critique in biblical terms, decrying the "gossip and slander" as antithetical to Christian grace. "Candace is grieving too, I get that," Stuckey conceded. "But turning Charlie's death into a revenge tour against his wife and his life's work? That's not justice; that's jealousy and ambition run amok." She urged listeners to "show grace" to Erika, echoing the widow's own Fox News plea last week for restraint amid the online vitriol: "What people share can affect my children—some grace would be nice."

The rift underscores a broader schism on the right, where once-united voices against "woke" culture now splinter over Israel, donor influence, and the boundaries of free speech. Owens, who parted ways with the Daily Wire in 2024 amid her own controversies, has leaned into anti-establishment populism, amassing millions of followers by "just asking questions" about everything from JFK parallels to alleged Israeli involvement in Kirk's death. Critics, including TPUSA insiders, whisper that her "leaked" texts—later verified as authentic by a TPUSA spokesman—were selectively deployed to sow chaos, with one anonymous source telling the Daily Mail that senior figures instructed staff to stay silent online to avoid "deepening the wound."

For her part, Erika Kirk has maintained a dignified silence on Owens specifically, channeling her energy into TPUSA's "This Is the Turning Point" tour, which kicked off last month with Vance at Ole Miss. But as Stuckey's intervention proves, the pressure is mounting. Online, hashtags like #JusticeForCharlie and #StandWithErika are dueling for dominance, while YouTube thumbnails scream "Erika Exposed?" and "Candace's Revenge." Will Erika finally break her silence, or will this toxic saga consume yet another pillar of the conservative ecosystem?

As one X user lamented amid the melee: "Why does Candace care more about who killed Charlie than his actual wife does?" For now, the answer remains as elusive as the full truth behind Kirk's untimely end—one that has left the right not just divided, but dangerously adrift.